Critical Analysis of Different Understandings about Martyrdom Concept
Introduction Martyrdom concept is a hermeneutical and dimensional fact. This description of martyrdom has been the root of different and diversified commentaries, understandings and paraphrases. The description has also caused different researches methods such as positivist and metaphysic ones. Before starting the subject, the researcher brings up two necessary questions:
1: Considering historic movement of thought and presenting settlement of that in form of knowledge liberalism and also forming philosophies in which lack of dependence is required for wisdom, philosophies in which there is a kind of desire for boundlessness and refraining from knowledge monopoly, wouldn’t discussing about martyrdom and similar concepts which contain ideological descriptions lead to being caught in the trap of disgusting ideology? That is while recent philosophers have named the contemporary era, the era of sunset for idols and death of ideologies. Recent philosophers have clearly spoken about instability of comprehensive metaphysics and meta-narratives.
War and Peace in the View of Philosophers: Main questions which are brought up in philosophic analysis of the subject can be categorized as follows:
A: Phenomenology of the concept of war and studying if war is basically an unfavorable and ominous and peace is an absolute value which we should continuously look for it? Or war is also a necessity in the life of human being and it is undeniable? And does it contain positive functions too?
B: Are all types of wars unfavorable and hateful? Or can we consider some types of war even holy and favorable considering motivations, results, equipments and method of war?
C: Isn’t a permanent and widespread peace an impossible and hard to achieve desire? Can’t we judge on the fact that many wars are undeniable according to this basis? Can’t we vote to the positive role of many of wars in removing war-making and destructive elements considering the fact that permanent and widespread peace is impossible? To answer these questions, we are obliged to refer to the history of philosophy. I try to discuss and evaluate the views of some famous western philosophers briefly in this part. In the philosophy of Greece, there are some philosophers such as Aristotle and Plato who has accepted truth of war despite the fact that they don’t admire it. They have accepted the truth of war either defending type or attacking type.
They have announced a war legitimate when interests of the city require it. Aristotle however has considered peace for the final of the war. He wrote in “Politics”? book as follows: “The life of men is divided between war and peace, work and rest. Some of the activities of people are necessary and some others are worthy. The priority should be attached to works which are done for rest and also the necessary and useful things for worthy things.”?
3 Aristotle has stated the goal of war as peace and comfort. According to him history shows that majority of warlike countries which started war, were safe by the time they were battling.4 We can continue study and analyze the subject of war in the thought of German philosophers such as Kant and Hegel. Emanuel Kant paid enough attention to individualism concept which was required for the concept of freedom. It should be mentioned that the freedom which was intended by him was not included in issues which could be understood by theoretical wisdom as other moral rules are not. Achieving to such concepts is merely possible with practical wisdom. Achieving this freedom requires independence of any inside and outside super power as well as imposing limitations.
Kant in his general thought has opposed militarism and using forces against people. He knows peace as the logic objective of any war. According to him, the less destructive the war is and the less revengeful is the peace conditions from the winner part, the longer and safer the achieved peace is. The only logic objective of any war is a relatively sustainable, useful and safe peace. The most important concern of Kant in this regard was to know the practical conditions to establish an eternal peace. Despite accepting necessity of use of force to support law in settled governments, Kant interprets the thought of using force for keeping international order useless both logically and practically.
According to Kant, settling international order will be possible when governments renounce starting war against each other freely. It should be mentioned that despite the fact that Kant knows war the root of all evil actions and moral corruptions, he insisted that every citizen should be ready to defend his country against foreign aggression. According to him, although war is the exaggerated form of natural pride, but defending oneself- either in national scale or personal scale- is a necessary and natural reaction. 6 Hegel is another German philosopher who discussed about war. Contrary to Kant, Hegel is a fearless admirer of war.
According to Hegel, civil wars root in contradictions between civil society (cities and citizens) and political society (Government and administrative system). And since there is no ruling in the international field, force if their last way to solve problems inside countries. Hegel defends civilizer characteristic of violence. According to him violence is the moment when the government reaches to the top point of self awareness. Hegel admired Napoleon till he had not been defeated. Hegel knew Napoleon as the manifestation of public soul in the public ace of warrior. Some critics believe that dialectic of Hegel has been the inspiration for Marx and Lenin to establish and strengthen communism foundation.
That is because Hegel believed that a nation which has been corrupted with peace will gain its moral health with war. According to him, war protects the sea from dirtiness caused after a long immovability. 7 Hence, we can briefly say that Hegel believed that war is an action that can strengthen social awareness of every nation with protecting spiritual unity against any type of individualism. He believes that war awakens the moral and political sense of responsibility of every citizen among the independence of ruling of the government. And in order to prevent separation of total existence of the nation from the special existence of individuals, it is the duty of the government to start a war and frighten the current structure of the nation and disturb the ordinary order. Hegel knows such military glories as the base of all political superiority. He calls the blind game with peace as the disgrace of thought and morality of our era. 8
Writer: Abdolhamid Ziyaee, PhD in Analytical Philosophy from Surbon University in Paris. The Professor in different universities of Tehran