Mysticism Changed the War into Sacred Defense
It is impossible to give an absolute definition for the word “Mysticism”? and say that “Mysticism”? has a particular meaning and nothing else. It may be exaggerating if we say: “Since the ways to reach to God are as many as the number of creatures, therefore, there are many ways to reach to mysticism too; but mysticism is not such a thing. How ever, to explain briefly, “Mysticism”? is a knowledge that makes human far from his inferior humanitarian existence and leads human towards the source of being [The whole existence] that is the same God. In this article, the writer makes efforts to analyze the mystic bases and elaborate on its connection with martyrdom. The writer studies the close connection of these two concepts in the battle fields of the sacred defense.
Abstract of the Article:
It is impossible to give an absolute definition for the word “Mysticism”? and say that “Mysticism”? has a particular meaning and nothing else. It may be exaggerating if we say: “Since the ways to reach to God are as many as the number of creatures, therefore, there are many ways to reach to mysticism too; but mysticism is not such a thing. How ever, to explain briefly, “Mysticism”? is a knowledge that makes human far from his inferior humanitarian existence and leads human towards the source of being [The whole existence] that is the same God. In this article, the writer makes efforts to analyze the mystic bases and elaborate on its connection with martyrdom. The writer studies the close connection of these two concepts in the battle fields of the sacred defense.
Key Words:
Mysticism and Sufism, the Sufi Sect, God, the Contemporary Literature, Combatant
Note:
Ebrahim Khodayar was born in Karaj City in 1966. He has graduated from the University of Tehran in the course of “Persian Language and Literature”?. He is the professor of “Tarbiat Modarres University”? at the present time.
As for his back ground in the field of news papers and the press; we can refer to establishing Sina Literary, Mystic and Cultural quarterly magazine. He has been also the editor-in-chief of this quarterly magazine. This magazine was published in Uzbek Language in Uzbekistan Country. He published 7 issues of this magazine since 2002 to the fall of 2003. Publication of this article still continues in Uzbekistan. Dr Khodayar had been the Head of Cultural Counsellorship of Islamic Republic of Iran in Uzbekistan since 1999 to 2003. He is a member of Scientific Board of “Research Center of Persian Language and Literature”? of “Tarbiat-e Modarres”? University at the present time. He is also the head of “Research Center of Persian Language and Literature”? and director of “Literary Criticism”? Magazine. These jobs are included in his scientific activities. He has written and published different books in the field of mysticism and literature by now.
As for his written and published books; we can refer to “Common Proverbs of Uzbek and Persian Languages”?, “The Garden with Many Trees”?, “Journey to the East”?, “From Samarghand like Sugar”? [The Word Samarghand consists of two parts of Samar and Ghand. And Ghand means sugar and sweetness], “Familiar Strangers”? and “The Complete Poetry Book of Mirza Hadi Samarghandi”?.
A History of Mysticism and Sufism:
Mysticism and Sufism are the schools of thought and methods for purifying the soul and spirit through which human cuts its relation from the earthly world and reaches to the heavenly world. This school of though is in fact the way of ascension of human to reach to the heaven.
The history of mysticism and Sufism goes back to the second and third centuries [2nd and 3rd based on AH Calendar]. As a matter of fact, if we want to study the history of Sufism as a school of thought and method, we go back to the 2nd century. And we find out that the first groups of Sufi people were formed in Iraq (Basreh and Koufeh) [Two cities in current Iraq] in the territory of Iranian civilization.
This school of thought later grew and developed. It was expanded and reached to Khorassan Province in the third and fourth centuries. This school of thought was mixed and grew with historical roots of Iran in past like the religion of Zoroastrian, Zarvani and other schools of thought which existed in ancient customs; it means the custom of Khosravani. It later divided into different branches. During these centuries, innocent and upright people such as “Rabe’eh Advieh”?, “Bayazid Bastami”?, “Ebrahim Adham”? and “Moshfegh”? appeared in the world of mysticism and Sufism.
As a matter of fact, we can say that mysticism and Sufism completely grew and developed scientifically and thoughtfully till the 6th and 7th centuries. We should not how ever forget the fact that the growth of Sufism group was done in the ground of Islam and traditions. The Sufi Sect grew and developed by taking cognitive aspects of Islam. The Sufi Sect found some similarities with other thinking groups out of Islam religion during some periods of time. And there have been how ever many discussions in this respect; but, the thinking bases and principles of the Sufi Sect were truly rooted in Islam and tradition. In fact, we can say: “Theoretical and cognitive aspects of mysticism and Sufism were rooted in Islam and its practical aspect is rooted in the tradition and behavior of Islam Prophet and his companions.”? [As their behaviors are narrated in history]
During the 7th century, the theory of mysticism and the Sufi Sect were some how formed by “Ibn Arabi”?. “Ibn Arabi”? established the theory of thinking bases of mystic people during previous centuries by writing “Fotouhat-e Makkieh”? and “Fosous ol Hekam”?. And he recorded these theories in his books.
We have not made an untrue claim if we say that no new thing was added to the bases and theoretical principles of mysticism after the 7th century and after “Ibn Arabi”?. It means that no new event occurred in the field of mysticism and Sufism during the next centuries. And the same previous thoughts, ideas and thinking bases are presented in a new form during the next centuries.
In this period of time, wonderful events occurred in the field of increasing branches of the Sufi Sect and its development in the world of Islam and the territory of Iran civilization; but in some countries, paying attention to mystic people caused strengthening of governmental bases in some ways. In fact, we can claim that majority of mystic people and Sufi people were not against governments. And that was the reason no government disagreed with them very much. It means that they did not disagreed with governments and stood against them, but also they did not pay any attention to the performance of the rulers. And this fact caused rulers of countries to continue to their cruel ruling on people.
As a surprising example of this fact in the history, we can refer to “Timur the Lame”? [It is pronounced as Teymour-e Lang in Persian. He was one of the rulers in Iran who was Mongolian originally whose ancestors had occupied Iran] who was a blood lust and dictator ruler; but this hateful and blood lust character carried his “Morad”? [Morad means the person that a Sufi person obeys and respects] where ever he went. And this sincerity resulted in burying him below the tomb of his “Morad”? when he died. This tomb still exists in “Samarghand”? [Samarghand is now in located in Uzbekistan and was a part of territory of Timor the Lame at that time].
As for one of the most important branches of mysticism; we can refer to “Naghshbandieh”? which surprisingly grew and developed in Asia Minor countries and lasted before the revolution in October 1917; But the interesting point lies where the concerns of all poets in this area was not similar in order that they can show the thinking bases and customs of “Naghshbandieh”? in their poems and many of proverbs of this branch how ever influenced in the public literature. Mystic branches of Sunni people prevailed in most places of Iran before the 9th and 10th centuries that Shiite Religion became the formal religion of Iran. And after the 9th and 10th centuries, Shiite branches of Sufi Sect such as “Ne’matollahieh”? and “Nour Bakhshieh”? prevailed in Iran.
Mysticism or Sufism
Since the beginning of branches of Sufi Sect, there were people that were not considered as Sufi people; because they believed that these branches pretended to be Sufi people in order to take advantage of facilities of thoughts of mystic people and the Sufi people for their own benefit.
The first book which is written in Persian Language in the field of Sufi Sect is titled as “Kashf –ol Mahjoub”?. This book is written by Jalali Hajviri and the writer has divided Sufi Sect branches into 12 groups by the time the book has been written.
Hajviri has mentioned two of these twelve groups as the branches which are out of the truth path. “Hallajieh”? and “Haloulieh”? are two braches which are rejected in this book. Therefore, we can observe well this concern since the basic time of forming Sufism. Islam clergymen have also rejected Sufi Sect in books such as “Talbis Eblis”? and other books. They believed that the words that the Sufi Sect says are in fact a kind of being deceived by the evil.
How ever, there have been agreements and disagreements since the time that the first branches of Sufi Sect were formed. These agreements and disagreements make it a little difficult to learn about this school of thought at the present time; because we can use this heritage appropriately in case we study pathology of mysticism and the Sufi Sect. therefore, accepting the opinions of opposing groups or those who agreed with this way of thinking in a certain way is not possible at all. And it is a lesson that is taught to us by the great mystics.
In a general look at poems said by “Hafez”?, we find out the fact that he had had no compatibility and agreement with hypocrisy and being religious in a slyly way. And the reason behind this fact lies in the deviations that were caused in Islam Religion by the Sufi Sect.
The general performance of mysticism and the Sufi Sect has been how ever very positive during the history. Mysticism is one of the main factors that strengthen the morale of liking people and supporting people without considering their colors and races. With such a reasoning, mystic people considered human being as a united body. Religion and way of living were not of importance for them; because they believed that actions and intentions were the main things that should be paid attention.
When the idea of liking people and supporting them found a way in the literature, it brought more enrichment for the literature. And if we are proud of the Persian Literature at the present time, it is mostly because of presence of mystic elements in the literature. We do not know any great and famous poet of Iran who has not been influenced by the mystic literature. Only “Fardowsi”? is excluded from this rule; because he has said poems about epic subjects.
When we read the books written by “Sa’di”?; we find out the fact that his prose and poems have an elegant spirit of mysticism. That is while “Golestan”? and “Boustan”? are moral books written by “Sa’di”?.
The life and works of “Molana”? – which has cheered the world now - is fully mysticism. And it is interesting to mention the fact that all religious groups attended his funeral ceremony when he passed away.
In one of his poems; he has said: “I feel unity with seventy two nations.”?
There is a story about “Abou Saeed”? in which we can observe mysticism in a complete way. It is narrated that: “One person refers to him one day. That person said that he wanted to become Muslim. Abou Saeed told that person: “You do not need to become Muslim”?. That man was very surprised and asked for the reason of his answer. Abou Saeed had asked him: “Have you left all your properties? Have you become ready to lose your life?”? That person answers: “Yes.”? Then Abou Saeed answers: “Then you are a Muslim.”?
What Does Mysticism Say?
But what is “Mysticism”? and what is its different with the Sufi Sect?
To answer this question; we should say that mystic people believed that human can reach to God by purifying the soul from abomination and impurity; but basic stages of piety are paid attention and focused in the Sufi Sect. for instance, “Avicenna”? [The Persian pronunciation for his name is “Abou Ali Sina”?. He was a great Persian physician and philosopher who lived since 980 to 1037 AD] has mentioned three groups in parts of Chapter 9 of “Esharat”? Book as “Zahed”? [Hermit], “Abed”? [Worshipper] and “Aref”? [Mystic]. This chapter of “Esharat”? Book is about mysticism and was written after a meeting with “Abou Saeed Abolkheyr”?.
“Avicenna”? has placed “Mystic”? person in a higher level that “Hermit”?. “Avicenna”? says: “Human passes through the stage of austerity and being hermit and reaches to the stage of worshipping God. And he finally enters the stage of “Mysticism”?. It is probable that one person passes through all these three stages; but a mystic person finds a deep view and insight compared to “Hermit”? and “Worshipper”?. For instance, a Sufi person may worship God with the hope of going to heaven; but the main concern of a mystic person is not heaven and hell at all. The main issue that a mystic person cares and thinks about is the issue of “Oneself”?.
For example; “Sanayee”? [A famous Iranian poet] has written as follows:
“Put steps out of both here and there! Be neither here nor there!”?
It means that neither this world nor the next world is beneficial for you. Both of them are obstacles for your way. And that is God that is the main target and subject.
“Mysticism”? reaches to deep insight and knowledge with the instrument of “Heart”?. And it is in contrary with what exists in philosophy. Philosophers believe that wisdom is the instrument for reaching to God.
Any how; it is impossible if we want to find a certain definition for “Mysticism”? and say “Mysticism”? is this particular thing and is nothing else. It may be exaggerating if we say: “Since there are ways to reach to God as many as the number of creatures, therefore, there are many ways to reach to mysticism too; but mysticism is not such a thing. That is why we can not give an exact definition for “Mysticism”? as the way it is in “Philosophy”?. How ever, to explain briefly, “Mysticism”? is a knowledge that makes human far from his inferior humanitarian existence and leads human towards the source of being [The whole existence] that is the same God.
Mysticism and Its Relation with Martyrdom
The Iranian mysticism has kinds of connection with martyrdom and religious bases; it means that when we focus deeply in mysticism, we can not omit religious bases and religious concepts from that; because this school of thought is rooted in Islam Religion. And Islam Religion has elements such as martyrdom which have been appeared in mystic schools of thought more or less. And the final target is the same in both of them. Mystic people say that they want to reach and connect to God. And it is the same way in martyrdom. Martyr wants to reach and connect to God.
The beauty of reaching a human to God through martyrdom is more than mysticism to some extent. It means that the distance that human should go through in order to reach to God through martyrdom is very shorter that the complicated way of mysticism which has thousands of dangers too. That is while human can reach and connect to God by martyrdom much easier. This subject has been pictured very beautifully by “Dr Pour Namdarian”? in the contemporary poem. He has said: “You can not find the highest stage of any mystic school of thought in any religion that its target is nothing except reaching to God and the truth. As a matter of fact, the martyr makes efforts with the target of reaching to the truth – that is the same God – and martyr tries to live in that high spiritual way.”?
“Dr Pour Namdarian”? has said few poems about martyrdom in the collection of poems of “Without Leaf Followers”?. One of these poems is titled as “Oh Enthusiasm of Reaching, Enthusiasm of Martyrdom”?. In this poem, he has brought up the subject of reaching to God.
In this poem, “Dr Pour Namdarian”? has said that martyrdom is also a kind of mysticism and it can be considered as the highest stage of mysticism through which human reaches to his final target much faster. In parts of this poem; he has said as follows:
“There is doubtlessly a sun rise after any sunset
But there is always a dark night in between”?
This “Dark Night”? mentioned in this poem refers to the earthly life in this world. And our life is in fact like this “Dark Night”? that is the distance between sun rise and sun set of the life of human. Now, the martyr does not focus on this “Dark Night”? and he does not see it. Martyr himself welcomes death and embraces it. The martyr immediately changes the sun set into sun rise. And a mystic person does the same work too; but he should pass through that “Dark Night”?.
In another part of his poem, he has said a verse that means you will how ever face with sun rise when the morning comes and death comes to you.
He has also said:
“Oh enthusiasm of reaching, oh enthusiasm of martyrdom
Enable us to hunt the death”?
It means that we can hunt the death through martyrdom and as a matter of fact, we go back again to the source of being [God]. And of course, it needs lots of bravery. Therefore, you will exactly face with religious literature is you want to find foot prints of the subject of martyr and martyrdom and its relation with mysticism.
It means that these foot prints started from “Seyf Forghani”? and reached to a peak in the poems said by “Mohtasham Kashani”? during Safavid time. As a matter of fact, the subject of martyrdom is brought up when ever mystic issues and religious mysticism subjects are discussed.
As an example, martyrdom of “Attar”? [A famous Iranian poet] is mixed in a fiction; but it is said that “Attar”? was martyred by Mongolian people. In this respect, we can also refer to the martyrdom of “Sheykh Najmeddin Kobra”? during the invasion of Mongolian forces to Iran. He manly and bravely stood against Mongolians. His followers told him: “Go to Kharazm. Mongolians may attack and you may be killed.”?
“Sheykh Najmeddin Kobra”? answered them: “I was with people in happiness. And I will not leave them alone in sadness either.”?
He resisted against the enemy by collecting stones and throwing them to the soldiers of the enemy. He was finally martyred in these battles.
There were how ever some people that did not resist against the invasion of Mongolians and ran away. As an example; we can refer to “Sheykh Najmeddin Dayeh”?, the writer of the Book “Mersad Al Ebad”?. He ran away and left his family and relatives alone. He escaped to the Asia Minor during the invasion of the Mongolians.
But you see that the subject of martyrdom has been how ever meaningful for some branches of mysticism too.
Living in this way and going towards martyrdom how ever needs bravery. It means that mysticism does not suffice such a life as a single element.
In another poem, it is referred to “Martyrdom”? by mentioning the Word “Tulip”? which has the color of blood.
This literature of “Pour Namdarian”? refers to the subject that martyrs have been so brave that they could go to heaven through the desert of earth [This world]. And they could be placed next to the green birds of the sky. This bravery is a kind of “Red Mysticism”?; a brave mysticism that can lead human to his final target by pouring his blood.
“Hallaj”? [Mansour Hallaj is a famous Iranian mystic, writer and teacher of Sufism. He was executed for heresy] is the martyr to the gallows of love. It is said in a poem about him: “The gallows became proud because Hallaj was hanged in that gallows.”?
Hallaj has said: “The prayer of love has two parts. And its “Vozou”? [Vozou means washing hands and face in a special way by Muslim people before saying prayers] should be certainly done by blood [It means that we should wash our hands and face with blood for saying this prayer. And it refers to the subject of martyrdom by saying washing hands and face with blood].”?
You see that “Martyrdom”? makes itself bare here and shows its truth in this sentence.
Mysticism of Martyr in the Contemporary Literature
The subjects of mysticism and martyrdom are brought up next to each other in the contemporary literature. The reason is clear; because you should pay the price if you want to reach to a goal. Some people should have donated their blood for the victory of Islamic Revolution. And the same blood should be poured again during war that our homeland was invaded. And our country should be protected. The reflection of these two historical events and the prices that should be paid for them can be observed well in the contemporary literature. There are poems, novels and memory writings in the literature that we know as “Sacred Defense Literature”?. And the subjects of martyrdom and sacred defense have been reflected well in this type of literature. According to the obtained statistics; approximately five thousand titles of books have been written in the field of sacred defense. It means that approximately four hundred books are written in this field every year.
All these are the reflection of literature of our resistance. And martyrdom is the main idea of this type of literature. And in parts of this literature, writers have focused on mysticism too.
The mysticism that we are speaking about is not in the way that our combatants have left the rules of war and followed mystic way of life as it is discussed in the theoretical mysticism; but our combatants said prayers all the night and it was not less that mystic way of living. Mystic way of living and behaving has its own special methods. Mystic people praise God all the time and they say special words to purify their souls.
But we should know the fact that most of combatants said prayers all the night in battle fields. They fasted and then they were martyred. In fact, the way of mystic behavior of martyrs of sacred defense and combatants in battle fields has been certainly different from what we already knew about mystic way of life and thinking; but martyrs of sacred defense had one advantage compared to martyred mystic people. And the advantage goes back to the fact that they behaved mystically in the battle field. And as Imam Ali has said: “They were pious people at night and combatant lions in the day.”? Most of combatants said prayers all the night and fought during the day and reached to their ascension.
By fighting, combatants aimed at defending our homeland and also reaching to God. And mysticism has commonality with combatants in the subject of reaching to God. Mystics wanted to reach to God too. And the martyr wanted to reach to God too. Mystics intended to reach to God and martyrs reached to this level; but martyrs passed through a one hundred - year distance during one night. And they reached to God much faster; but behaving in mystic way and obeying its rules have thousands of dangers.
There is a couplet of poem said in this regard which comes as follows:
“Do not step into the road of love without any reason
Because I myself made the best efforts and could not reach any where”? in the mystic way of life, the mystic needs a leader who shows him the correct and incorrect ways. Martyrs in battle fields had one leader like Imam Khomeini. And they had one high spiritual goal on their minds that was reaching to God. They could reach to this goal by the bravery that was in their hearts.
Pathology of Contemporary Literature about the Concept and Meaning of “Martyrdom”?
In some forms of contemporary literature such as memory writing and almost poetry, contemporary literature has been able to show some aspects of the mysticism that appeared in battle fields; but other forms such as novel and short story, contemporary literature has not been able to include the subject of self sacrifice and martyrdom and their relations with mysticism well. And characters could not be pictured similar to the ones that existed in battle fields in novels and stories.
When we take a look at the Novel “War and Peace”? written by “Leo Tolstoy”? –which is translated into all live languages of the world – we find out the fact that we have not yet created such a novel in our contemporary literature that reflects realities of our war to the world as powerful as “Tolstoy”? did in his novel.
To answer to the question why we have not had such a novel about our war, we should find the answer in the answer to hundreds of questions which are brought up regarding our contemporary literature.
Has our contemporary literature become global that we expect and ask why the contemporary literature in the field of war has not become global?
There have been how ever many good words said in our literature of resistance. And a large number of books have been published in this field every year. And even the martyrdom of mystics has been discussed; but our contemporary literature has not focused on this subject.
Most of contemporary poets and writers have shown interest to this subject during these years. As an example, “Akhavan Sales”? [The famous Iranian poet] has said poems about the homeland and martyr in his last poetry book under the title of “O love you my old country”?.
And many other poets and writers have written about the subject of martyr too; but it seems that few works have been written in this field which have transferred this concept to the audience well.
The reason may how ever go back to a “Hadith”? [A sentence said by imams or the prophet] that means the person who has not tasted some thing, can not understand it.
Most of our classic writers have learned and have been involved in mysticism. They understood the enthusiasm and feeling of a mystic person; that is why they could transfer their idea well when they started to write some thing in an atmosphere of mysticism.
But in the field of sacred defense literature and even sacred defense cinema, the people [writers and artists] - who were not present in battle fields – could not transfer the concepts well. As a matter of fact, they could not become close to the subject. These realities are parts of a whole named “Literature”?. It means that you should be both concerned about these subjects and have understood and experienced the atmosphere of battle fields. And it means you [writer or artist] should have both seen a martyr closely and you should have the capability of a writer in a professional way.
I do not how ever mean to question “Sacred Defense Literature”?. I even agree very much with what have been written in this field during these years.
But the fact is that we should pay much more attention to our sacred defense literature if we still want to write books and poems, etc about martyr and the mysticism appeared in the battle fields of war during next year. Artists should make efforts to make their artistic works closer to the real characters of combatants. These artistic works may be poems, novels, stories, films and even paintings and sculptures. These art works should speak about the mysticism and ideas that appeared in our war which made it different from other wars in the world.
We should not forget what changed our war into sacred defense was the “Mysticism”? in the atmosphere of battle fields.
Notice:
All dates which are mentioned based on centuries are according to AH calendar. Those which are based on Christian calendar are written as exact date or year or it is followed by AD.
Writer: Dr Ebrahim Khodayar
Member of Scientific Board and Professor of “Tarbiat Modarres University”?